Fifth Sunday of Lent
She’s Not Mary Magdalene
In the movie, “Passion of the Christ” a flashback depicts Jesus’ defending the woman taken in adultery. Unfortunately, the movie says that the woman was Mary Magdalene. This misidentification goes back to the days of St Gregory the Great (590 – 604 AD). It has taken years for people to try to clarify the misidentification; unfortunately, the movie which was a “must-see” for many adult Catholics re-introduced the error widely once again.
The memorable story which constitutes our Gospel today appears in John 8. However, for years, biblical scholars have felt that this Gospel would be more appropriate to the Gospel of Luke (which is the Gospel that we hear from this liturgical year.)
There are two salient reasons for feeling this Gospel was really divinely inspired in St Luke. First, the clear championing of the woman hints at Luke’s preferences in depicting Jesus. Jesus appears again and again as the One Who prefers those looked down upon by Meditterrean culture as the special objects of God’s amazing love. Such people include the following: the rejected, the old left behind, the lepers, the shepherds, the Samaritans, the poor, the sinners and women.
The woman, today, represents several of these categories in today’s Gospel. Male dominated Jewish society sees her as a criminal, a sinful woman, who deserves punishment for upsetting the good order of society. (Did you ever wonder about the man in this story?) The picture portrays cultural values that are stacked in favor of some and opposed to others.
Jesus cuts through the blindness of such boundaries by establishing the Kingdom of God, viz., God’s New World Order“.
Second, Jesus believes that when some view others as bad, that does not automatically make the viewers good. The very fact that the crowd was going to stone the woman, they were indicating that, through a violent action, a society can purge itself of evildoers, thus maintaining its societal purity. (Some states in our country still go through this ritual periodically to purge themselves of evildoers (who are frequently poor and non-white)). These days, when our nation ranks with
Jesus understands then, as well as now, that not only individuals, but more importantly, groups (of any size) buy into a self-righteousness that tends to identify another or others as bad and hence, dehumanized. Ordinary folks do that all the time with negative feelings about others. Groups, cultures and even countries do the same thing all the time as well. When you label others as deviant for any reason, you tend to de-humanize them. When you de-humanize them, you do not feel the obligation to treat them the same way that you treat others who are in your (so human & perfect ) camp.
People, groups, ethnic and racial and religious entities, as well as nations can learn a valuable caveat from Jesus in this very beautiful Gospel story. Jesus wants us to treat everyone as God sees us – all in-group, all flawed, all-loved. 032507AD jfq